Matthew’s Pizza
3131 Eastern Ave, Baltimore, MD
Voted best in Baltimore a number of times, I finally got around to checking it out. I wasn’t disappointed.
Order the Both Cheese Pie (Large) and Margherita (Large) . Both pies out the door for $20. A really good value.
The Both Cheese pie has a satisfying crust blended with a bright tomato sauce and a generous amount of cheese. The crust was almost sponge like on the inside, making a nice texture contrast to the crunchy exterior. The cheese blend was fantastic, with just the right amount of tartness. The sauce was the only disappointment. Not seasoned at all, it tasted of crushed tomatoes from the can. A little bit of seasoning and perhaps, a pinch of sugar could make this pie a 10/10. As it stands, a solid 8.5/10.
Not a traditional Margherita by any means. Thick, chewy crust. A little on the greasy side. A nice topping of fresh tomatoes, chopped basil and good mozzarella. At this point, the crust could really shine, and the balance of the fresh tomatoes with the tart cheese and sweetness of the basil made for a wonderful bite. A solid 9.5/10.
